France heads toward bankruptcy and Phoenix Capital Research sees another country following

France faces an increasingly difficult fiscal equation as public debt balloons, its servicing costs escalate, and political conditions limit the government's ability to implement meaningful adjustment. According to Graham Summers, chief market strategist at Phoenix Capital Research, recent developments in the sovereign bond market serve as a warning sign regarding the sustainability of French debt, as well as the broader fiscal vulnerabilities of developed economies. Summers' core argument is that France struggles to curb its debt through spending cuts, tax hikes, or faster economic growth, while lacking the monetary policy autonomy that would allow it to finance the state through its own central bank. His warning is clear: France could become the first major developed economy where markets begin pricing in the risks associated with public debt with particular intensity. And, as he maintains, it will not be the last.

Bond market alarm - French debt deemed riskier than Italian and Greek debt

On October 2, the yield spread between 10-year French and German government bonds widened to approximately 150 basis points, according to data cited by Summers. This marks the highest level since the Eurozone sovereign debt crisis in 2011, when Greece, Italy, and Spain faced severe market pressures. The development is particularly significant because, according to the article, the yield spread of French bonds over German bunds was wider than that of Italy, at roughly 90 basis points, and Greece, at roughly 76 basis points. In other words, investors demanded a higher risk premium to hold French public debt compared to equivalent Italian and Greek debt, reflecting an elevated perception of risk. Another point cited by Summers is that on October 8, investment-grade corporate bonds issued by French companies, totaling approximately 215 billion euros, offered lower yields than comparable French sovereign bonds. This means investors were willing to lend to specific French corporations at a lower cost than what they demanded to finance the French state itself. The yield spread subsequently narrowed, reaching about 132 basis points last Friday. However, according to Summers, this easing does not negate the deeper problems of the French economy.

€3.6tn public debt - At 119% of GDP

At the end of the second quarter, France's public debt approached 3.6 trillion euros, corresponding to approximately 119% of GDP. According to Summers, this is the highest level since 1946, when the country was attempting to rebuild following World War II. The French budget's own forecasts, he notes, place the debt-to-GDP ratio at 121.7% next year. Meanwhile, the budget deficit is expected to settle at 5.4% of GDP this year, one of the highest ratios in the European Union. Summers points out that the last time France posted a balanced budget was in 1973, when Richard Nixon was US president. For next year, the French state is expected to borrow a record amount of 340 billion euros—28 billion euros more than this year—to cover the deficit and refinance maturing bonds. The continuous need for new borrowing renders the country particularly vulnerable during periods when markets demand higher yields to finance public debt.

Interest costs exceed even Education spending

The cost of servicing French debt is increasing at a rapid pace. According to forecasts cited by Summers, French state interest payments are expected to rise from 64.8 billion euros this year to 74.2 billion euros in 2027. Interest payments now constitute the single largest line item in the state budget, surpassing even expenditures on Education. The problem is that this burden has not yet been fully reflected. The average maturity of French government bonds stands at approximately 8.5 years. This means a significant portion of debt issued at near-zero interest rates during the 2010s and early 2020s is gradually being refinanced at today's higher rates. Consequently, even if markets stabilize, interest costs may continue rising for several years as older borrowing is replaced by costlier new debt.

Why France cannot easily tackle the crisis

Graham Summers argues that France faces four key constraints: it cannot independently print money, struggles to cut spending, has limited room for new taxation, and is not growing fast enough to stabilize debt.

1. Cannot print its own currency

France lacks an independent monetary policy. The Banque de France does not autonomously set interest rates and monetary strategy for the country, as those competencies belong to the European Central Bank (ECB). Unlike the US or Japan, where central banks can purchase government bonds to curb yield pressures, France cannot unilaterally mobilize its own central bank to finance the public sector. Euro membership implies that addressing a sovereign debt crisis depends heavily on European institutions and the rules of the monetary union. The ECB does possess the Transmission Protection Instrument (TPI), which provides for the potential purchase of member-state bonds when market pressures are deemed unjustified relative to fundamental economic data. There is, however, a critical limitation: a country's eligibility is tied, among other factors, to its compliance with the European fiscal framework. France has been under an excessive deficit procedure since July 2024. Summers argues this creates obstacles for a potential activation of the TPI in the country's favor. This specific tool had not been utilized as of the article's publication, nor, according to him, had there been any public indication from an ECB official that its activation for France was being considered.

2. Political deadlock on spending cuts

The second major difficulty concerns the political feasibility of implementing austerity measures. Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu leads a minority government. On October 1, he presented a budget for 2027 projecting spending cuts and revenue-raising measures totaling 43 billion euros, aiming to curb the deficit to 5% of GDP. Lecornu himself has warned that without savings, the 2027 deficit could approach 6.5% of GDP. Securing parliamentary support for such a budget, however, remains a difficult task. Public sector workers have already launched strikes over proposed wage restraint. Meanwhile, the government agreed the previous year to suspend Emmanuel Macron's flagship pension reform in order to preserve its political survival. According to Summers, this development contributed to S&P downgrading France's credit rating to A+. Fitch had already downgraded the country to the same tier the previous month. The political problem is set to intensify ahead of next year's presidential elections. According to Summers, polls leave open the possibility of a far-right victory. In an environment where public spending accounts for over half of GDP, political pledges to cut pensions and healthcare are particularly difficult to implement.

3. Room for tax hikes has narrowed

France already possesses one of the highest tax burdens among developed economies. This year's budget relied, among other things, on extraordinary tax burdens on very high earners, large corporations, and family holding companies. Summers warns that further tax hikes have limits, as excessive burdens can drive capital and skilled labor abroad. Thus, fiscal adjustment may fail to yield the required revenues without collateral impacts on economic activity.

4. Growth is insufficient to stabilize debt

The fourth problem concerns sluggish economic growth. The Banque de France projects GDP growth of just 0.5% this year. When the economy expands at such a low rate and the budget deficit remains above 5% of GDP, public debt risks growing faster than the economic base called upon to service it. The result is a vicious cycle: high debt, mounting interest payments, restricted fiscal space, and low growth.

The risk from foreign investors

There is, according to Summers, a fifth risk factor: the holder composition of French public debt. Nearly 57% of French government bonds are held by non-residents, as the article notes. Foreign investors do not share the same political or institutional ties with Paris that domestic institutional investors might. If they judge that the risk-reward ratio is no longer attractive, they can scale back their positions. Mass bond sell-offs would drive prices down and yields up, increasing the French state's future borrowing costs. This could further worsen the fiscal picture and trigger fresh selling, reinforcing a self-fulfilling cycle of pressures.

From France to Belgium and Japan - The debt crisis can spread

Summers clarifies that he is not predicting an immediate French default within the coming month. He maintains, however, that the country serves as a prime example of a major developed economy where markets are beginning to question whether public debt can be curbed under current financing terms. At the same time, he notes that France does not even post the largest fiscal deficit in the Eurozone. Belgium recorded a deficit of 5.2% of GDP the previous year, compared to 5.1% for France, according to data he cites. The broader problem concerns the fiscal strategy pursued by many developed economies over the past 15 years. Governments increased borrowing in an environment where interest rates hovered near zero, assuming financing costs would remain low. Rising interest rates upend this assumption and bring the consequences of debt accumulation to the forefront. Summers links these developments to the potential bursting of the "Everything Bubble," as bond market pressures in France and Japan reveal, in his view, the limits of long-term reliance on cheap money.

Why capital may flee to US Treasuries

The question is where capital will flow if investors begin withdrawing from European sovereign debt markets. The historical experience of the 2011 crisis offers a potential answer, according to Summers: U.S. Treasuries. During the Eurozone debt crisis, capital fled European sovereign bonds and headed toward American government debt. Inflows were so strong that the yield on the US 10-year Treasury note dropped below 2% in the weeks following S&P's stripping of the US's AAA top credit rating. The US faces serious debt problems of its own. However, it commands the world's primary reserve currency, the largest and deepest bond market, and a central bank capable of purchasing sovereign securities. According to Summers, if the European debt crisis enters a new phase, the US may once again serve as the primary destination for capital seeking safety and liquidity.

The ECB intervention scenario and the inflation risk

For investors, Summers considers developments in France to be an important warning regarding how a sovereign debt crisis can unfold. In his assessment, when a country loses control of its bond market, the ultimate solution often involves central bank intervention through sovereign debt purchases, even when institutional or regulatory constraints exist. As a precedent, he cites 2012, when then-ECB President Mario Draghi pledged to do "whatever it takes" to save the euro. Summers estimates that money creation to sustain a monetary union could fuel inflationary pressures. In such an environment, assets such as gold, energy, and companies operating in their production could, in his view, benefit. This is his personal investment assessment rather than a certainty regarding market trajectories or future ECB decisions.

The promotional pitch behind the warning

At the end of the article, Graham Summers refers to a special report by Phoenix Capital Research titled Survive the Inflationary Storm, which presents, according to him, the investment choices he deems appropriate for an environment where governments may resort to monetary financing to tackle their debt problems. Summers notes the report normally retails for $499 but is offering 100 free copies to readers of the Gains, Pains & Capital newsletter. This commercial pitch forms part of the context in which the analysis must be read: the article combines warnings regarding France's fiscal standing with the presentation of specific investment ideas. Summers' core conclusion is that the era of near-zero borrowing costs has passed and accumulated fiscal vulnerabilities are returning to center stage. France represents, in his view, one of the most striking examples of this shift, with bond markets acting as the ultimate arbiter of public debt sustainability.

www.bankingnews.gr